Pudgie's

Reviews about Pudgie's

• 1 / 5

  By Lindsay Collins
  Ordered for the first time tonight and wont do it again. My order was estimated to be delivered at 8:40 but did not arrive until 9:20. I understand that it's just an estimate but fourty minutes past that time is excessive. My pizza is cold and I mean cold- it doesn't even feel slightly warm and the cheese has solidified like it's been sitting for a while. My manicotti is hot but is also extremely burnt. The container it came in has a black ring of burnt crispiness around it. Seems like my pizza was made when my order was placed and sat out for an hour while my manicotti was forgotten in the oven in the mean time. The quality of it definitely should have called for them making a new one and never sending this out. If I knew my order was going to take an hour and a half for this quality, I would have spent my fourty bucks elsewhere.
  February 10, 2017
• 4 / 5

  By Lori Langendoerfer
  The Waverly, NY franchise is one of the best in the area!!! The food is always good and every time we go to Sayre, PA we stop in here to grab a bite to eat. The one in Ithaca, NY used to be really good, but has taken a turn over the last years. Much more worth the drive to Waverly, NY!
  December 20, 2016
• 1 / 5

  By Al C
  Don't bother... ordered on a weeknight. Pizza was completely burnt and I do not mean crispy I mean overcooked to the point it was all one color. Meatball sub, which as you know has cheese on it was wrapped in foil, and any 4th grader knows that if you wrap a hot sandwich with melted cheese in foil without wax paper first it will stick... Well this group of individuals apparently did not realize that. Oh and thanks for the order of fries, all 9 of them. YUP 9 of them. Plenty of other options...
  December 11, 2016